Which Fence Is Best for Your Garden? Start With the Problem You're Solving

Short answer: there is no single best fence. A closeboard timber fence on concrete posts is the best all-rounder for a typical UK back garden on a budget. Slatted designs handle wind better. Railings or picket suit front gardens. PVC or composite make sense if you never want to paint again. Decide what the fence has to do first, and the material usually picks itself.

Most disappointing fences fail at a job nobody named at the start, such as a lattice top in a garden with a jumping spaniel, or a solid 6ft panel on a hilltop. These are the situations we hear about most, with what works in each.

"I want privacy on the patio"

A solid 1.8m fence is the standard answer. Closeboard timber, a tongue-and-groove PVC panel and composite boards all block sightlines completely. In a small garden, a solid wall of fence can feel heavy. A panel with a lattice or slatted top keeps privacy at seated height and lets light through above.

The limits:

• No fence stops you being seen from an upstairs window next door. Trees, a pergola or a sail shade do.
• A standard fence does little for noise. Domestic panels are far lighter than a proper acoustic barrier, and sound goes over the top. Expect a small improvement at best.

"My garden is windy"

Wind is what flattens fences in the UK, and solid panels catch the most. In order of how well they cope:

1. Slatted or hit-and-miss timber, or open styles. Wind passes through, and hit-and-miss still screens most views.
2. Closeboard on concrete posts. It is heavy and stiff, and individual boards can be replaced.
3. Solid panels of any material, with bigger posts, deeper footings and closer spacing.

Lap panels are the worst choice for an exposed site. Our article on windy gardens goes into posts and footings.

"It's a front garden"

Height decides most of this. In England, a fence next to a highway used by vehicles (including its footpath) can usually be no more than 1m high without planning permission. Most front fences are therefore low and open:

• Picket in painted timber or white PVC for cottage and new-build frontages
• Railings for Victorian and Edwardian terraces
• Low walls with a hedge where the street is mostly brick

Look at what your neighbours have. A front boundary that matches the street almost always looks better than one that doesn't.

"I need to keep a dog in"

Height and the bottom edge matter more than material. For most medium and large dogs, 1.8m of solid fence is a sensible minimum. It still isn't a guarantee for an athletic or determined jumper. Remove anything a dog can use as a step, like bins, benches and log stores. Close gaps under the fence with a gravel board, or bury mesh for diggers. Dogs Trust recommends checking the boundary regularly for weak spots.

Avoid horizontal rails on the inside face. To a dog (or a child) they are a ladder.

"We have small children"

Children need a boundary they can't climb or squeeze through, and gates that close by themselves. Vertical boards or pickets with no footholds on the inside face, self-closing gate hinges and a latch out of reach do most of the work. If there is a pond, RoSPA advises filling it in or covering it with a rigid grille while children are under five. A fence around it should be at least 1.1m with self-closing gates, but still don't rely on it alone.

"The ground slopes"

There are two ways to fence a slope:

• Stepped: panels stay level and drop down at each post, leaving triangular gaps underneath that need filling with gravel boards.
• Raked: the fence follows the slope. This is easy with closeboard, post-and-rail and some picket systems, but not with rigid square panels.

On a steep or uneven run, closeboard built on site is usually the most forgiving choice.

"I don't want to maintain it"

Be realistic about what "maintenance" means for each material:

Composite and PVC cost more upfront. They pay back in time, not always in money, and how much that is worth depends on how long you'll stay.

"I'm on a tight budget"

Buy the best posts you can afford and a cheaper infill. Closeboard on concrete posts with gravel boards is good value. Lap panels on timber posts are the cheapest to buy, and often the most expensive over ten years.

A quick way to decide

Write down the one thing the fence must do (privacy, security, containment, looks or low maintenance) and the one thing it must cope with (wind, slope, dogs, a road). Then:

• Privacy + wind → slatted or hit-and-miss timber, or solid panels on stronger posts
• Containment + children → vertical boards or pickets, self-closing gates
• Looks + front garden → picket or railings at 1m or under
• Low maintenance + long stay → PVC or composite

If white PVC is on your shortlist, the Complete Fence Planner gives you a full parts list and price for your exact layout, so you can compare it fairly against a timber quote.

FAQ